Home
Sean Williams
ten reasons to call myself 'un-australian' 
27th-Nov-2006 11:04 am
It, HC Headshot, copernicus 2, outhouse, magic dirt, fly, saucer men, grattis, flight to mars, unleashed logo, Orphans head, gedosenki A, man from planet X, WOTF 23, saturn returns, crab monsters, fingers, cenotaxis, saturn title, psycho, changeling close, red moon, destination moon, zombie, boot, Movember 1, suicide pistol, squid, haiku, energy dome, inflatable dalek, beach, silent p, dalek & madonna, dog collar, earth ascendant, dalek & kylie, squid fancy, Movember 3, dirt 1, Movember - FZ wallpaper, city painting, south park, seth bullock, askew, aurealis head, Movember 2, glitter negative, trouvelot mars, Washington, destination: prague, gedosenki C, pink pills, Movember - FZ water, bert, Wig, bear, Mischevious, kev07, Lodo, tux, movember - wolfman, cosmic monsters, denied a voice, trouvelot nebula, russian egghead, sorry, kittens, blob, tubeway, glitter - not, unleashed, pirate, kb's party, gedosenki B, berserker, Movember - FZ black, hanging mountains, quantum lolcat, beast with 10000 eyes, Gazza, cenotaxis - audible, killers from space, destroy all monster, cosmic man, wedding 1, magritte, invaders from mars, robot, fringe ticket, in the name of the law, gary numan ticket, goldfrapp A&E, copernicus, giant claw, numan's eye, green sun, trouvelot jupiter, simpsons, Imre, PEN, saturn returns - audible
...whatever that means. (Here, here, here and here are four opinions on the matter.)

(1) I don't drink beer. Having discovered in recent times that it makes me unwell, even at small doses, I've had to give my beloved Coopers Pale Ale the flick. I miss it on hot days, but otherwise feel much better for the lack of it.

(2) I don't follow a football team of any code, despite the government's confident assertion that "Australians love their 'footy'". The same site describes attending a football match as "[a] serious ritual, [which] involves proudly wearing team colours, barracking for favourite players, and engaging in enthusiastic cheering". As someone who has friends who enjoy similar activities relating to science fiction television shows, but for which they are generally mocked, I can't help feeling resentful of the hypocrisy.

(3) I experienced only short-lived (and, imho, entirely appropriate) moments of sorrow, the same one feels for any family of a person who dies unexpectedly, over the deaths of Peter Brock and Steve Irwin.

(4) I was raised in Adelaide and the Northern Territory, and as a result I feel little kinship with any of the characters from or the landscape portrayed in "The Man from Snowy River" (a point raised by Adrian Mitchell in his fascinating collection of essays Drawing the Crow).

(5) I am troubled by this country's widely divergent attitudes towards Schapelle Corby and the Bali nine. Surely our national objection to the death penalty should not be contingent on whether the accused is a hottie or not.

(6) I have no interest in how Australia performs in the Olympics, the soccer, the cricket, and the Commonwealth Games. Nor does the Melbourne Cup hold any fascination for me, as a historical, cultural or social artefact.

(7) The conditions endured by a large percentage of Australia's indigenous population fill me with a deep sense of shame. Our sweeping of the invasion of their territory under the cultural rug, likewise.

(8) I prefer winter to summer, and would much rather settle in by the fire with a good book and a glass of wine than join the glistening throngs in their thongs at the beach. Sweat and sand are a terrible combination, imho, although I do like fish and chips at sunset, over the west-facing coast of home.

(9) I didn't vote for John Howard and I find the behaviour of this country under his leadership morally bankrupt, short-sighted and internationally embarrassing, not just on such issues as international justice for our fellow citizens and indigenous relations, but euthanasia, industrial reform, religion, welfare and the privatisation of public utilities. Bring back Paul Keating, I reckon.

(10) I am depressed by how, even in this list, sport demands far more attention than it deserves, over such issues as investment in science, the environment and international humanitarian crises.

There. That's it. Am I proud of this list? Feeling superior for it? Not at all. It's no fun feeling at odds with one's own culture, as presented in the media and perhaps genuinely felt by most people. To paraphrase that fun old saw: you don’t have to like Cold Chisel , live on the East Coast, or eat Vegemite to be an Australian, but it helps.

(Having said all this, I am reassured to learn that, according to What Do You Think? I live in a country in which the following statements received strong support: both genders share equal responsibility for the care of children; we should be alert for but not alarmed by the possibility of a terrorist attack in Australia; democracy is threatened by the Coalition Government's stranglehold on both lower and upper houses; tertiary education should be free, as it used to be; and the blue Wiggle is best.)
Comments 
27th-Nov-2006 01:11 am (UTC)
deadcities_icon
The conditions endured by a large percentage of Australia's indigenous population fill me with a deep sense of shame. Our sweeping of the invasion of their territory under the cultural rug, likewise.

Wait, I thought you lived in Australia, not America....?

27th-Nov-2006 01:20 am (UTC)
I do. The notion of "invading" rather than "settling" is a hot topic down here, but I fail to see the ambiguity. People were living on the continent before we arrived; they resisted our expansion fairly consistently, everywhere contact occurred; they're not in charge any more. That's not to say that there wasn't good and bad on both sides; I just don't think it helps anyone to mince words on the subject.

All "imho", of course, although I hope the tide is turning.
27th-Nov-2006 01:25 am (UTC)
deadcities_icon
I do. The notion of "invading" rather than "settling" is a hot topic down here, but I fail to see the ambiguity. People were living on the continent before we arrived; they resisted our expansion fairly consistently, everywhere contact occurred; they're not in charge any more. That's not to say that there wasn't good and bad on both sides; I just don't think it helps anyone to mince words on the subject.

Ah, yes. That was pretty much my point. Succinctly put by my "Thanksgiving" post, I think.
27th-Nov-2006 01:36 am (UTC)
Sorry for missing the point, Gabe. :-) I am nervous of being so overtly political...

Nice post, btw. At least we don't celebrate our screw-ups down here (unless Australia Day counts).
27th-Nov-2006 02:15 am (UTC)
deadcities_icon
Oh, please, be political. Everyone should wear their politics on their sleeves!






(it'd make it easier to aim when I decide to go shooting then...! heh...)
27th-Nov-2006 02:34 am (UTC)
deadcities_icon
Hey, Sean... I just emailed you. I hope I sent it to the proper address. Let me know if you didn't get it.
27th-Nov-2006 01:20 am (UTC)
Well said... utterly well said. I feel this myself (minus the beer... never liked the stuff :P)

*hugs*
27th-Nov-2006 01:22 am (UTC)
Thanks! We must share a G&T or a glass of ice-cold champagne one day in celebration of our likemindedness. :-)
27th-Nov-2006 02:36 am (UTC)
bring on the sharing of something sweet and delightfully alcoholic :) when you're next in perth let me know and we'll find cocktails or g&t's or soemthing else that will no doubt get us all into trouble :P
27th-Nov-2006 01:55 am (UTC)
Quote: "(5) I am troubled by this country's widely divergent attitudes towards Schapelle Corby and the Bali nine. Surely our national objection to the death penalty should not be contingent on whether the accused is a hottie or not."

Or whether it is politically convenient to encourage it, cf the Bali bombers. cf also (9) above*. :(

*Fairness compels me to admit, however much I might hate doing so, that privatisation was a major part of the Hawke-Keating agenda so that can't be blamed entirely on the souless ones currently in power.

27th-Nov-2006 02:00 am (UTC)
Agreed on both points, even though I hate to cut Howard any slack at all. :-)
27th-Nov-2006 06:41 am (UTC)
I agree with you on all those points (except that I left Adelaide for WA when I was six, prefer autumn to the other seasons, and I don't like Vegemite), but [info]arcadiagt5 is right: bringing back Paul Keating wouldn't have been the answer. Even Gough, I was appalled to learn, considered revoking free university education if he was returned to power, in the hopes of balancing the budget.

That's not to say that I didn't give my preferences to Keating over Howard; I did, even though I didn't know quite how despicable Howard was going to become once he was Prime Miser, or how long he'd cling leechlike to power. But I really would have liked another choice.
27th-Nov-2006 06:50 am (UTC)
Hear hear. It's probably fair to say that no politician will ever be perfect, but I'm already mourning the loss of Our Natasha...
28th-Nov-2006 02:59 am (UTC)
"But I really would have liked another choice."

"but I'm already mourning the loss of Our Natasha..."

Its a pity we'll never get another choice; that was decided when Janine Haines made her attempt to get into the House of Reps as a Democrat. Natasha was relevant as a balance holder in the Senate, but the Democrats were never going to be more than that.

All these years later it still rankles when I remember watching the Liberal/Labor preference swap that was designed to avoid that at all costs. And it worked.

I believe the Greens experienced something similar in the recent Victorian election: Independents can be tolerated but better a Liberal than a Green in the lower house. (If its a Liberal party apparatchik speaking substitute "Labor" or "National" for "Liberal").
27th-Nov-2006 02:22 am (UTC)
Well, I can't say I'm with you on 1. I like beer (and wine, and all manner of other alcoholic beverages). Nor am I with you on 8 - Perth in summer is glorious, Perth in winter is a wet and dull.

But I am certainly worried that the values of the country appear to be changing, and that we even seriously talk about unAustralianness is a worry.

On number 10, I cringe knowing that there are probably more people in Perth who could name every member of the Eagles than could name one of our two recent Nobel Prize winners. Well, any of our Nobel prize winners, probably.
27th-Nov-2006 03:22 am (UTC)
... that we even seriously talk about unAustralianness is a worry.

Indeed.
27th-Nov-2006 04:35 am (UTC)
Just for the record, I still like wine. Too much, probably. :-)

"Un-Australian" smacks of "un-American", especially in the current political climate. Sigh.
27th-Nov-2006 03:19 am (UTC)
I must be un-Australian, too, as I can relate to most of your points.

But I do enjoy the Olympics and Melbourne Cup, and barracking for Australia, or random horses - though perhaps on a slightly ironic level.
27th-Nov-2006 03:47 am (UTC)
Sounds like I must be unaustralian too, does this mean they're going to revoke my citizenship and send me back where I came from? (Perth (Australia) winters may be dull and wet but they're warmer than Scottish ones)
Closest I've gotten to alcoholic drinks is LLBs, watching sport is even duller than playing it (and the only sports I play are usually non contact social ones). I can't stand vegemite either (but then it may be something you have to grow up with)
27th-Nov-2006 04:10 am (UTC)
What rubbish. Seriously. Even in mock calling any of those positions "unAustralian" is to accept the way the John Howards of the world define "Australian". I do not.

There have always been Australian who hold many if not all of your positions. There have always been Australians troubled by this country's history. Just take a read of Capricornia. Or any of Henry Reynolds' books.

Those positions are held by many many many Australians. Including me (except about the cricket). So how the hell could they possibly be UnAustralian? We may be a minority, but we're a bloody big minority.
27th-Nov-2006 04:31 am (UTC)
What rubbish. Seriously.

This post or the discussion of whether the notion of being un-Australian has validity? I can't argue with the former, if that's your opinion, but I think the latter is worth discussing, especially when one of the references I cited refers to "Men who like cats, bosses who block internet access to footy tipping websites...anyone who refuses to eat lamb or support Lleyton Hewitt...Striking workers, utes that can't do burn-outs, broadcasting the Ashes on pay TV, paying for beach access or for someone to clean your house..." and so on. Light-heartedly or otherwise, that these are being connected with a sense of national disengagement, as though they're really important, bothers and unnerves me. Letting the matter be raised and not addressed, I reckon, is to let the John Howards have their way. I'd hate that.

Note, just for the record, that my post was about "reasons to call" myself un-Australian. I know that the only way to truly become un-Australian would be to revoke my citizenship, and I have no desire to do that. Vive la difference--as long as la difference is not just allowed, but acknowledged as a fundamental part of a healthy society.
27th-Nov-2006 04:42 am (UTC)
But why call yourself un-Australian? That's accepting the very objectionable terms that John Howard and his like have set up. Which is deeply wrong. We have to refuse their terms.

The idea that holding any of the opinions you outline makes you un-Australian is what is rubbish. Your opinions have a long long history in this country. They don't come out of nowhere. Racism has long history in this country, but so does the fight against it. Both things are very Australian.
27th-Nov-2006 05:09 am (UTC)
Ah, okay. I get you. The term itself has a long history, too, and is far from an invention of John Howard's regime. I guess I'd rather fight for the definition of the term than over its existence. The notion of a philosophical opposite, while possibly meaningless in everyday life, surely has some value in idle discussion. What else do I call myself, if the term exists and is being applied that way at the moment?

Really, what I'm talking about is my feeling of being at odds with the vast majority of things I see in the paper and on TV, and hear on the radio and even on the lips of people on the bus. No doubt everyone could produce a list of things they dislike about their country, but I'm hard-pressed to find one uniquely and widely accepted as Australian thing that I can embrace. I like the books of Gail Jones; I like your books too, Justine; I do actually like Vegemite, but it's not so different from Marmite and Promite (which I also like) so I'm not sure it even qualifies; I think our landscape is to die for, but most people think of SA as a wasteland fit to dump nuclear waste in or strip-mine for uranium; I think Powderfinger are over-rated; our reality TV shows are rip-offs of overseas versions, like most of our dramas and talk-shows (the ones that work, anyway); we occasionally make the odd good movie and, yes, we have some great scientific minds struggling on, against the odds; but you must see that I feel as though I'm already scraping the bottom of the barrel, and that quickly becomes a bit depressing.

At least you like cricket. If I just had that, maybe I wouldn't feel quite so shut out of my own country.
27th-Nov-2006 10:55 am (UTC)
You know what's interesting? The vast majority of people I hear spinning this line---like you---have never lived anywhere but Australia. I used to feel the way you feel, but living in Spain totally changed my perspective. And living in the US even moreso. I stopped buying the narrow mainstream version of Australia and when I went home I started seeing just how limited that version is and how much more diverse our country is.

And, no, Sean, John Howard didn't event the term---it comes from the idea of un-Americanism and is every bit as bogus. One of the things that makes me proud to be Australian is that in the 1950s at the height of the anti-Communist insanity Australians voted solidly against criminalising the Communist Party.

I'm sick of folks like us allowing the right to monopolise love of country. Patriotism shouldn't mean uncritical love. I don't love anything uncritically---not my husband, not my friends (hence us having this excellent argument), not even Elvis, and certainly not my country.

You, my friend, are quintessentially Australian. The self doubt, feeling of alienation, and not belonging has been a big fat ole theme in Australian lit since before My Brilliant Career. (Ever read it? Tis chock full of ambivalence about being Australian.) The misfits, the sentimental blokes, the rabble rousers, the wowsers are as quinteessentially Australian as any blue-eyed, blond-haired surfer boy.

I'm sick to death of this tediously narrow definition of Australian being taken even slightly seriously. You know what? I know plenty of non-Australians who like all the so-called Australian things like beer and football and meat pies with sauce and cricket and Kylie Minogue. So what? If you were born here or have spent most of your life here then you were shaped by this culture (diverse as it is) and you're Australian.

You are; I am; even bloody John Howard (rot his eyes) is.
27th-Nov-2006 05:14 am (UTC)
Racism has long history in this country, but so does the fight against it. Both things are very Australian.

I'd also say that both things are very human, rather than uniquely Australian.

However some of the items on my list might blur into a discussion of what's moral or not, as opposed to what's "Australian" and what's not, so I'm prepared to take a bollicking on my original point there. :-)
27th-Nov-2006 10:55 am (UTC)
And so you should, mister.
27th-Nov-2006 11:10 pm (UTC)
But only ever from you.
28th-Nov-2006 04:45 am (UTC)
Best friends forever!

Sorry that my first response was so grumpy. It was early in the morning (in Bangkok) and I hadn't eaten yet . . .

You're still wrong, but. :-)
28th-Nov-2006 09:05 am (UTC)
Hurrah! And no worries at all. Just waking up in Bangkok is enough to make anyone grumpy. What a crazy town...

You're still wrong, but.

Force of habit. :-)
27th-Nov-2006 04:45 am (UTC)
There is a delicate balancing act here though.

Within limits differences are essential to a vibrant healthy society. Mongrel vigour is a term I've heard in this context.

The limit, and its extremely hard to define, is when a group identifies its differences as being more important than its membership in the society as a whole.

My concern here is with extremists of all stripes. I guess this makes me a fanatical moderate which is amusing in ironic kind of way. :)
27th-Nov-2006 10:56 am (UTC)
Oh sure. There's always the scary danger that Sean and other malcontents will get together stage a coup and then ban cricket. The horror!
12th-Dec-2006 04:50 am (UTC)
I'll play cello at the celebratory gig after sport is banned.
12th-Dec-2006 06:25 am (UTC)
Hurrah! That's a future to look forward to.

Honestly, though, I don't mind if people enjoy sport. I just wish they'd keep it to themselves--out of the paper, off the TV and the streets--and pay for it themselves. I bet the publishing (or music) industry doesn't get half the tax breaks and funding as sport. We don't have a National Writing Institute, despite the amount of export dollars writing brings in. Etc.

I could rant on all day, but I won't in case Justine comes and hits me over the head with a cricket bat. :-)
27th-Nov-2006 12:21 pm (UTC)
I agree with pretty much all of those points, so I guess I'm with you on being unAustralian.

But it makes me wonder, just what *is* Australian anyway? This country is such a melange of different cultures and viewpoints and seems to be changing from day to day.
27th-Nov-2006 11:12 pm (UTC)
I suppose I'm railing against any crystallization of being "Australian" into a particular set of values. We are definitely a wonderful mix of many wonderful traits, and I'd hate that ever to change.
27th-Nov-2006 12:41 pm (UTC)